Elden Ring is a massive game, so chances are good that it’ll take more than one playthrough to see everything. Seeing as how starting new game plus in Elden Ring is as easy as resting at the Roundtable of Lost Grace and selecting the "Begin Journey 2" option, it can be tempting to do so without making any preparations. Don’t do that. There are certain things that can only be done with most of the map accessible and most of the stores unlocked. If one wants to start new game plus on the best possible footing, there are a few steps that should be taken first.

Step 1: Square Up

In a game as massive as Elden Ring, it's easy to miss a few bosses. Since many of them have valuable unique drops, it's worth it to go out there and get them felled before moving onto new game plus. High-priority targets should include Erdtree Avatars, Deathbirds, Night's Cavalry and the Bell Bearing Hunters. Dragons, evergaol dwellers and NPC Invaders are all important too of course, but those are all best covered in another guide. Out of of those though, Black Knife Tiche and the Mimic Tear should be the top priorities.

Erdtree Avatars drop crystal tears for the flask of Wondrous Physic, which can grant the player various unique buffs upon consumption. Since there are so many potential builds and situations in Elden Ring, it's worthwhile to get as my tears as possible before starting a new run. There are seven avatars in total and they can be found in the following locations:

  • Weeping Peninsula: He's chilling directly underneath the Minor Erdtree in the middle of the peninsula.
  • Liurnia of the Lakes: One is Found along the road to the Minor Erdtree in the southwestern section of the map. Another is encountered on the northeastern side of the lake.
  • Leyndell Royal Capital: It'll be seen on the main road. It's not considered a boss, but should still drop something good.
  • Deeprooth Depths: Hangs out near the Great Waterfall Crest grace. It's also not considered a "boss"  but drops the "Erdtrees Avatar" staff all the same.
  • Mountaintops of the Giants: Can be fought at the Minor Erdtree located to the east of Stargazer's Ruins.
  • Elphael, Brace of the Haligtree: This one is also another non-boss. It chills on the ring walkway and drops the Rotten Staff.

Five Putrid Avatars can also be encountered in Caelid, Haligtree and Consecrated Snowfield as well. Expect to get crystal tears from those seen in Caelid and Consecrated Snowfield.

Deathbirds (and Death Rite Birds) are worth taking-out for two reasons: they're too ugly to be left alive, and they give all sorts of interesting loot. Some drop weapons, others drop shields, while still others drop talismans and other stuff. It's worth hunting down all eight monstrously hideous birds, but encountering them often depends on the time of day.

Deathbirds:

  • Limgrave: Likes to chill to the east of the Warmaster’s Shack in Stormhill. Defeating it means getting the Blue-Feathered Branchsword.
  • Weeping Peninsula: Shows up under the cliff to the north of Castle Morne and drops the Sacrificial Axe.
  • Liurnia of the Lakes: Swoops-in near the Scenic Isle grace and drops the Red-Feathered Branchsword talisman.
  • Capital Outskirts: It appears to the east of the Hermit Merchant's Shack.

Death Rite Birds:

  • Liurnia of the Lakes: It stalks the area around the Gate Town North Site grace, but only at night.
  • Caelid: It'll show up between the Aeonia Swamp Bank grace and Sellia Gateway. Again, only at night.
  • Mountaintops of the Giants: Shows-up to the southwest of Castle Sol along the cliffside, and it drops the Death Ritual Spear.
  • Consecrated Snowfield: Appears at the beginning of the frozen river, west of the Ordina Liturgical Town. This one also only appears at night and drops Explosive Ghostflame upon defeat.
Elden Ring - Nights Cavalry

Night's Cavalry appear depending on the time of day too, but they're always seen at night. All of them either drop their signature armor/weapons or valuable Ashes of War like the Bloodhounds Step. The final two Night's Cavalry encountered in Consecrated Snowfield even leave an extra Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone for players who manage to defeat them. The ten Night's Cavalry can be found in the following spots:

  • The Limgrave member like to chill on the bridge near Agheel Lake North.
  • In Weeping Peninsula, this guy can be found wandering around near Castle Morne Rampart.
  • For Liurnia South, he'll be chilling around Gate Town Bridge.
  • The Liurnia North rider favors the area just south of Bellum Church.
  • The Caelid cavalry patrols around Caelid Highway near the merchant. It will attack even if the player is talking to the merchant, so watch out.
  • The Dragonbarrow rider: sticks close to the bridge near Lenne's Rise.
  • One can be encountered in Altus Plateau just south of the Altus Highway Junction grace. He could be the very first enemy encountered there if one is lucky.
  • The Forbidden Lands guy stalks the path from the lift. If the player arrives at night, he can't be missed.
  • Consecrated Snowfield is something of a special case. Two Night's Cavalry will be guarding a Hearse near the Inner Consecrated Snowfield grace. Both riders must be defeated to get the drops. They leave the Night's Cavalry armor and an Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone, so seek them out.

As for Bell Bearing Hunters, there are four in total, they all appear at night, and they're all inexplicably tough. As with all the previously-mentioned boss enemies, though, the rewards are often worth it. Each hunter awards a special bell bearing upon its defeat, enabling players to gain easy access to high-level materials and more. Track them down at the following locations and bring that A-game; they'll punish anything and everything less.

  • Bell Bearing Hunter (1) - fight this guy at Warmaster's Shack in Stormhill.
  • Bell Bearing Hunter (2) - he shows up inside Church of Vows, which is a little east of Liurnia of the Lakes.
  • Bell Bearing Hunter (3) -  he hangs out at Hermit Merchant's Shack in the Leyndell Royal Capital.
  • Bell Bearing Hunter (4) - this meanest of the hunters waits near the Isolated Merchant's spot in Dragonbarrow.

Step 2: Clean Up

Once all the remaining high-priority bosses have been dealt with, players may want to consider channeling their efforts into sniffing out any remaining dungeons. While this may seem easier said than done, there are a couple of ways to hone-in on their locations.

Elden Ring - Guide Statue
ELDEN RING™_20220422221424

The first of these is the Guide Statues. These statues resembling a creepy old woman can be found all over The Lands Between and they always point to a dungeon. If one is encountered, make sure to approach and check it. If there's a button prompt, hit it and follow the ghostly trail of light that emerges; it'll surely lead to a nearby dungeon. If no button prompt appears, then one can (usually) rest assured that they've already cleared the area's most important hidden spot. Aside from the statues, it's usually just good to just be extra thorough and look for hidden drops or not-so-obvious dips in a cliffside. Unexplained concentrations of enemies are also a good indicator.

Step 3: Stock Up

Okay, so now that most of the bosses have been defeated and most of the dungeons have been found and looted, the only thing left to do is spend all those extra runes at the Twin Maiden Husks Shop in Roundtable Hold. All bell bearings (and the items they unlock) are lost upon starting new game plus, so it's best to buy up as many rare consumables, materials and smithing stones as possible before starting that next run. New game plus is all about playing around with new weapons and such, and it's much easier to do that with a well-stocked inventory. Don't worry about banking runes, there will be plenty more of them in the next run. The best thing to do now is spend 'em!

Elden Ring - Walking Mausoleum

Also, make sure to also find all the Walking Mausoleums and duplicate any Rememberances one might have on hand. In general, secret bosses Rememberances should take priority since they're more difficult to seek out, but then it's more about what one does and doesn't want to do in their next playthrough. Don't want to beat a boss again but do want all their stuff? Duplicate. Going to fight 'em again? Maybe don't duplicate. In case it's needed, here's a list of Walking Mausoleum locations, just remember that only the ones with bells are able to duplicate major boss rememberances.

  • Weeping Peninsula: Strolls around the area to the east of the Isolated Merchant's Shack.
  • Liurnia of the Lakes (Central): Walks in the water in front of  the Raya Lucaria Crystal Tunnel. The skulls on top must be destroyed from above using a bow. Do so from the nearby tombstones jutting out from the cliffside. They can be accessed by first warping to the East Raya Lucaria grace and heading east to the cliffside.
  • Liurnia of the Lakes (Northeast): Two are chilling in the area around the Mausoleum Compound grace. It's the area to the north of the Church of Vows.
  • Deeproot Depths: hangs out near the  Nameless Eternal City grace. This one is also accessed by destroying the skulls on the top rather than on the feet. Do so by dropping down onto it from the roots above or shooting them with a bow.
  • Mountaintop of the Giants: It's just outside of Castle Sol. It shouldn't be difficult to miss.
  • Consecrated Snowfield: It's just outside the Apostate Derelict grace. Unlike all the rest, this one goes on the offensive and will continuously bombard the area with magic until you bring it down.

Having completed each of these steps, the time to start new game plus will have arrived. After clearing all available bosses, acquiring all available gear/spells/incantations and stocking up on rare items, The Tarnished should be all set for another, hopefully much smoother, journey through The Lands Between. One more tip: go and immediately wreck Grafted Scion, Tree Sentinel, Flying Dragon Agheel and Margit the Fell Omen. Paying them back in full for all the early game pain suffered at their hands is beyond satisfying.